Toilet Training
- An important milestone for children and parents
- One of the first real opportunities a child is given to independently manage an activity of daily living
- Recognizing signs of readiness
- Guidance on methods of toilet training
When Should We Start?
- Age varies by time, culture, and definition of endpoint of toilet training
- US: 98% children are potty-trained by 36 months
- Digo people in East Africa begin toilet training infants during first weeks of life, usually achieve stooling and urination on command by 4-5 months old
- A study out of Belgium in 2000 showed the age at which children begin to toilet-train has increased over time
- US: Daytime vs nighttime bladder control
- Nighttime bladder control not expected until 5-7 years of age
Toilet-Training Methods
1) Parent-oriented:
- Structural-behavioral training and operant conditioning
- Speed training, increased fluid intake, regularly scheduled toilet times
- Positive reinforcement for correct elimination
- Overcorrection for accidents
2) Child-oriented:
- Only after certain criteria of readiness are met
- Permitting the child freedom to master each step at own pace
- Fairly rapid training time, high rates of continence, low rates of regression
Assessing Readiness
Child:
- Physiologic: Sphincter control (reflex ~9-12 mo, voluntary conditioning ~12-15 mo)
- Developmental: Ambulate, stability while sitting, remain dry for several hours, pull clothes up/down, language skills (receptive to follow command/expressive to communicate need to use toilet)
- Behavioral: Ability to imitate behaviors, place things where they belong, show independence by saying “no,” expression of interest, diminishing oppositional behaviors/power struggles
- Toilet-training should not be delayed in children with chronic illness
Parent:
- Clinicians should discuss toilet training with parents at each health supervision visit beginning at age 12 months
- Plan toilet training when at least one caregiver can give the time/energy necessary to be consistent on a daily basis for a minimum of 3 months
Choosing a Potty!
- Once the child demonstrates readiness, parents can bring a potty into the home
- Encourage child to play with it, set it where he wants, sit on it fully clothed, to help with “ownership”
- Some place the potty in the bathroom, some find greater success by keeping the potty in the bedroom where it is easily accessible after a nap, or kitchen after a meal
- Deciding on a vocabulary for bodily fluids to use consistently
- After a week of sitting on the potty fully clothed, child should be encouraged to sit on the chair naked
- Placing a soiled diaper or stool in the potty and explaining that this is the purpose of the chair
- Demonstration of disposal of the feces or the urine into the “adult” toilet
- Transition to training pants or cotton underwear after at least 1 week of success using the potty
Toilet-Training Tips!
- Pretend play even before starting toilet training
- Reading kids books on toilet training
- Trying not to refer to pooping as “stinky” or “smelly” (try not to make them averse to the toilet)
- Positive reinforcement
- Sounds of toilet or disappearance of feces may scare child, can try encouraging them to flush toilet paper itself or wave “bye-bye” to feces before flushing
- “It’s not a reflection of your parenting, every child is different!”
Children with Intellectual Disability
Length of time to establish bladder training:
- Nonverbal > verbal
- Intellectual disability > no intellectual disability
Operant conditioning principles:
- Scheduled bathroom visits based on identified patterns of voiding
- Nonverbal “toileting language” (e.g. pictures, sign language, gestures)
- Increasing fluid intake
- Reinforcement/rewards
- Treating and preventing constipation, which may provide negative reinforcement
Setbacks & Problems…
- Enuresis
- Resistance/refusal
- Constipation/withholding behavior
- Toilet training may set the stage for child abuse
Take-Home Points!
- Age at which toilet training happens, varies by country, time, culture
- Parent-oriented model versus child-oriented model
- Assessing readiness of child by physiologic, developmental, and behavioral cues
- Using the potty training toilet to help the child transition
- Every child is different, not a reflection of parenting
Further reading (and listening)!
- AAP educational materials
- Healthy Children: Toilet Training
- PedsDocTalk podcast: Everybody Poops!
Blog post based on Med-Peds Forum talk by Ann Ding, PGY3